Vier collegejongens maken graag overal een pesterijtje van. Totdat het een keer misgaat en een meisje overlijdt. De vrienden verbergen het lijk en proberen de zaak te vergeten. Acht jaar later echter belt één van hen - inmiddels een crimineel - de rest op.
Nee, helaas is What We Did That Night nog niet beschikbaar op Netflix in Nederland.
| Directing | Paul Shapiro | Director |
| Writing | Eric Harlacher | Writer |
| Production | Judy Cairo | Producer |
| Production | Jon Cowan | Executive Producer |
| Production | Judith A. Polone | Executive Producer |
| Camera | Brian J. Reynolds | Director of Photography |
| Editing | Craig Bench | Editor |
| Art | Maria Caso | Production Design |
| Art | Michael D. Costello | Art Direction |
| Art | Damon Medlen | Set Decoration |
| Costume & Make-Up | Elisabeth Scott | Costume Design |
| Costume & Make-Up | Sari Lietzman | Key Makeup Artist |
| Costume & Make-Up | Steven Mack | Hair Department Head |
| Directing | Jeffrey M. Ellis | First Assistant Director |
| Art | William Apperson | Construction Coordinator |
| Art | Greg Huyck | Property Master |
| Crew | Dale Gibson | Stunt Double |
| Camera | Milena Albert | Still Photographer |
| Camera | William Clouter | Key Grip |
| Camera | Alan Koplin | First Assistant "A" Camera |
| Editing | J. Randolph Harrison | Assistant Editor |
| Directing | Karen Eachus | Script Supervisor |
