Josh Hutton keert terug in zijn oude woonplaats nadat hij in de gevangenis gezeten heeft voor moord. Bij terugkeer ontmoet hij Audry Hugo. Niemand kan zich precies herinneren wat Josh gedaan heeft, maar iedereen is bang voor hem, vooral de vader van Audry.
Nee, helaas is The Unbelievable Truth nog niet beschikbaar op Netflix in Nederland.
| Directing | Hal Hartley | Director |
| Writing | Hal Hartley | Writer |
| Costume & Make-Up | Kelly Reichardt | Wardrobe Supervisor |
| Camera | Michael Spiller | Director of Photography |
| Production | Bruce Weiss | Co-Producer |
| Costume & Make-Up | Judy Chin | Hairstylist |
| Costume & Make-Up | Judy Chin | Makeup Artist |
| Production | Bob Gosse | Production Manager |
| Art | Carla Gerona | Production Design |
| Production | Jerome Brownstein | Executive Producer |
| Production | Hal Hartley | Co-Producer |
| Art | Sarah Stollman | Set Decoration |
| Lighting | Joe Cochran | Best Boy Electric |
| Sound | Nick Gomez | Sound Recordist |
| Directing | Ted Hope | First Assistant Director |
| Camera | Tami Reiker | Second Assistant Camera |
| Sound | Jeff Kushner | Boom Operator |
| Camera | Heather White | Additional Second Assistant Camera |
| Camera | Sarah Cawley | First Assistant Camera |
| Lighting | Tory Estern | Additional Gaffer |
| Camera | Anne Gwynn | Additional Second Assistant Camera |
| Camera | Rich Breen | Additional Grip |
| Camera | Neil Shapiro | Additional Second Assistant Camera |
| Art | Steve Rosenzweig | Graphic Designer |
| Directing | Peter Grand | Continuity |
| Camera | Richard Ludwig | Still Photographer |
| Sound | Reilly Steele | Sound Re-Recording Mixer |
| Directing | Ann Ruark | Script Supervisor |
| Lighting | Frank Stubblefield | Gaffer |
| Sound | Jim Coleman | Original Music Composer |
| Art | Daniel Ouellette | Property Master |
