Portret van twee vermeende stalkers van Tiffany, die in de jaren tachtig een hit had met I Think We're Alone Now. Jeff en Kelly zijn ervan overtuigd dat Tiffany van hen houdt, dat ze een intieme vriendin is. Interviews met hen en hun kennissen onthullen veel over deze meer dan hartstochtelijke fans.
Nee, helaas is I Think We're Alone Now nog niet beschikbaar op Netflix in Nederland.
| Writing | Sean Donnelly | Writer |
| Directing | Sean Donnelly | Director |
| Editing | Sean Donnelly | Editor |
| Camera | Sean Donnelly | Additional Camera |
| Crew | Phil Buccellato | Cinematography |
| Production | Phil Buccellato | Producer |
| Production | Sean Donnelly | Producer |
| Production | Jordy Cohen | Producer |
| Sound | Palo Colorado | Music |
| Sound | Alessandro Minoli | Music |
| Sound | Cyrus Shahmir | Music |
| Editing | Phil Buccellato | Editor |
| Sound | Charlie Tighe | Sound |
| Camera | Eugene Park | Additional Photography |
| Camera | Jordy Cohen | Additional Camera |
| Camera | Ariel Schulman | Additional Camera |
| Editing | Dave Reaves | Assistant Editor |
| Sound | Malcolm Francis | Music Supervisor |
