Een ongelooflijk toeval leidt ertoe dat filmmaker Jay Rosenblatt zijn schoolklas van de bassischool weet terug te vinden, alsmede de onderwijzer van die klas. Hij onderzoekt bij hen wat ze zich nog weten te herinneren van een toenmalig voorval van pestgedrag, van zo'n vijftig jaar geleden, en wat hun aandeel hierin is geweest.
Nee, helaas is When We Were Bullies nog niet beschikbaar op Netflix in Nederland.
| Sound | Erik Ian Walker | Original Music Composer |
| Camera | Paul Foster | Director of Photography |
| Camera | Kirsten Johnson | Director of Photography |
| Camera | Ellie McCutcheon | Director of Photography |
| Camera | Jay Rosenblatt | Director of Photography |
| Camera | Jerome Rosenblatt | Director of Photography |
| Camera | Roberta Rosenblatt | Director of Photography |
| Sound | Pete Horner | Sound |
| Sound | Judy Karp | Sound Recordist |
| Visual Effects | Jeremy Rourke | Animation |
| Editing | Robert Arnold | Colorist |
| Editing | Robert Arnold | Color Grading |
| Editing | Jim Farber | Online Editor |
| Editing | Summers Henderson | Online Editor |
| Sound | Michele Walther | Musician |
| Writing | Ellen Bruno | Script Consultant |
| Writing | Stephanie Rapp | Script Consultant |
| Writing | Caveh Zahedi | Script Consultant |
| Production | Shaleece Haas | Production Consultant |
| Production | Lucas Morrison | Researcher |
| Directing | Jay Rosenblatt | Director |
| Writing | Jay Rosenblatt | Writer |
| Production | Jay Rosenblatt | Producer |
| Production | Elena Filippini | Producer |
| Production | Stefano Tealdi | Producer |
