Danielle heeft een goede baan en is verloofd met Todd. Op een dag komt Danielle weer in contact met Danny, een oude vlam van de middelbare school. Danielle vindt het leuk om Danny weer te zien, maar hij gedraagt zich obsessief en kan het verleden niet laten rusten. Danielles leven komt op zijn kop te staan als Todd plotseling verdwijnt.
Nee, helaas is The Wrong High School Sweetheart nog niet beschikbaar op Netflix in Nederland.
| Writing | Robert Dean Klein | Writer |
| Production | Nancy McManus | Casting |
| Sound | Marc Ferrari | Music Supervisor |
| Production | Vivica A. Fox | Producer |
| Writing | Jeffrey Schenck | Story |
| Directing | Conor Glantz | First Assistant Director |
| Camera | Ben Stevenson | First Assistant Camera |
| Sound | Mark Sutton | Production Sound Mixer |
| Art | Lisa Stevens | Art Direction |
| Art | Albert Gomez | Property Master |
| Art | Steven Song | Set Dresser |
| Costume & Make-Up | John Jacobs | Key Makeup Artist |
| Costume & Make-Up | Roberta La Roux | Key Hair Stylist |
| Costume & Make-Up | Christina Mitchell | Makeup Artist |
| Costume & Make-Up | Kenya Alexander | Hairstylist |
| Editing | Mark Noad | Online Editor |
| Editing | Allen Kelly | Colorist |
| Sound | David Michael Erwin | Sound Designer |
| Sound | Dave Moorman | Sound Re-Recording Mixer |
| Sound | Jeff Noller | Dialogue Editor |
| Sound | Mark McBryde | Foley Artist |
| Directing | David DeCoteau | Director |
| Production | Barry Barnholtz | Executive Producer |
| Production | Zelma Kiwi | Executive Producer |
| Production | Jeffrey Schenck | Executive Producer |
| Production | Jan Glaser | Casting |
| Visual Effects | Joseph J. Lawson | Visual Effects |
| Production | Peter Sullivan | Co-Producer |
| Production | Brian Nolan | Co-Producer |
| Sound | Chris Cano | Original Music Composer |
